Media4EU

At press conferences debriefing today’s EU27 Summit, the French and German leaders differed by more than nuances.

Here are straight quotes, to avoid translation losses:
– Francois Hollande stated: ‘Ce mandat [exit negotiations] sera exercé par le Conseil, avec l’appui de la Commission européenne, et celui du Parlement car c’est l’émanation, aussi, de la légitimité européenne’
– Angela Merkel spoke just before: ‘Die Verhandlungen werden von allen drei Institutionen geführt. Vor allem von der Kommission, in einer zentralen Rolle, mit Ihren Sachkenntnissen, Möglichkeiten, and Erfahrung der Beitrittsverhandlungen.’
Later she clarified that the Commission would follow the political guidelines of the Council, and the EP would accompany the negotiations, since it later has to approve the results in majority vote. She stressed again negotiating on behalf of the whole Union ‘in ihren drei Komponenten.’

(Why was she mentioning enlargement experience? Thinking already of re-enlargement negotiations? Here am I only speculating. On this point, Merkel was speaking freely, not reading a prepared briefing)

Yesterday, differences of tone appeared between the Presidents of the Council and of the Commission: Juncker markedly more agressive and less patient toward the UK government.

Putting this into perspective: which process drives what outcome?
This questions of negotiation leadership often arises, for example in trade talks (where competence differs between good and services). For Brexit, it has been in the talk since last week, and is more important than it seems: the Commission stands for the acquis communautaire, also relevant for access to the Common Market. While the Council is traditionally more open to government wishes, including (still member) UK.

Asked the same question on Monday evening, a senior EU diplomat was trying to spin in favour of the Commission. He pointed to the Treaties, and then to other negotiations. For him, the Commission managed to transform banking decisions into draft law in 6 days, working day and night, while the Council takes several months to transform migration policy into decisions. Is this a fair comparison? I am not sure.

Interestingly, during the Cameron package negotiations in February, it is ‘EU federalist’ Belgium that insisted the deal would vanish in case of a Brexit vote. Clearly, to avoid salami tactics and rewarding the UK with an even better deal leveraging a Leave vote. And guess who the Council just nominated to lead (its part of) the negotiations? A Belgian diplomat!

The French President seems to wish a tough line toward the UK, and also have a more direct say via Council leadership. Which could open negotiations to more interference from other Member States with special wishes, or UK allies…
The German Chancellor seems more patient and flexible, but would give leadership to the – tougher – Commission.
Two paradoxes! In other words, the processes they seem to push for do not reflect their actual objectives.

Next steps? Before Bratislava on 15 Septembre
Since most continentals agree that (formal) negotiations cannot start before UK triggers article 50, where are in the pre-positioning stage. Both between UK and the EU, and also between EU institutions. No doubt, the objective should be to clarify this over Summer, during ‘COREPER 27’ talks in the run-up to the Bratislava Summit.

@LeclercqEU

Author :
Print

Comments

  1. Plate of mixed greens contains such sustenance that make us solid yet snacks are bad for the wellbeing. I value this post sharing this excellent learning and making individuals mindful of the sustenance and great nourishment, from cheap thesis writing service we can make individuals consider taking sound sustenance and keep up their wellbeing by taking solid sustenance.

  2. Brexit is now most discussing thing and discussion are going on all around the world and the world is seriously looking into this news. Thesis writing service uk is planning to write an essay based on this topic.

  3. Hey, excellent writing!
    Food manufacturers often put small amounts of healthy ingredients in their products to fool people into thinking their products are healthy. There are companies that try to change their labels to look more healthy and there are companies that are dedicated to creating the healthiest food and products possible.

    DON’T TRUST YOUR HEALTH TO JUST ANYBODY

    We are your healthy lifestyle advocates. https://healthy-finds.com/

  4. In order to perform instructional achievement through a result orientated method presented by using expert writers then seeks the offerings of Custom Essay Writers UK. We deliver high first-rate of original, plagiarism loose paintings on time at low-cost fees. Specialized assistance for all your topics and topics at the side of complete studies and numerous precious references and citations from real resources.

  5. these two football grounds are nearest in England. Amid the 2009– 10 battle City Ground football arena will be the eighth biggest arena in Football League Championship. parimatch

  6. Can I simply just say what a comfort to find somebody that really knows what they’re discussing on the internet.
    You definitely understand how to bring an issue to light and make it important. finance assignment help
    More and more people really need to read this and understand this side of your story. It’s surprising you’re not more popular since you certainly possess the gift.

  7. You shared a very informative post with us and I am happy to found your post. Find the best essay help with the creation of essays and other writings from cheap essay writing service and they possess the professionally qualified writers who give the best assistance.

  8. Thanks for every other informative blog. The place
    else may just I am getting that kind of information written in such a perfect way. click here for online shopping

  9. There are organizations that attempt to change their marks to look increasingly solid and there are organizations that are devoted to making the most advantageous nourishment and items conceivable. Macys Insite Login.

  10. Thanks a lot for sharing such valuable information. Generally I used to get the same kind of data from
    this website but this site have much better data.

Leave a Reply